Little Italy in New York City is a historic and vibrant neighborhood that offers an authentic Italian dining experience, steeped in tradition and rich in culinary delights. Here’s a guide to help you navigate the best restaurants in this iconic area.
Historical Significance and Atmosphere
Little Italy, once a bustling immigrant neighborhood, is now a popular tourist destination known for its romantic, old New York atmosphere. The area, primarily centered around Mulberry Street, is filled with the best Italian restaurants, trendy clothing stores, and some of the top bars in NYC[3].
Top Recommendations
Il Cortile
Located at 125 Mulberry St, Il Cortile has been a staple in Little Italy since 1975. This family-run restaurant is renowned for its northern Italian cuisine, exceptional service, and signature dishes like mozzarella-stuffed meatballs and Fettuccine di Parma. It also offers pre-fixed menus ideal for group events and a lovely garden atrium for a unique dining experience[2][5].
Da Nico
For those craving delicious pizza, Da Nico at 164 Mulberry St is a must-visit. This restaurant offers rustic Italian-American fare, including brick oven pizzas and a divine courtyard where you can enjoy your meal. Don’t forget to try their powdered sugar zeppoles for dessert[2][5].
Gelso & Grand
Situated at the corner of Mulberry and Grand, Gelso & Grand is perfect for big groups and family gatherings. Known for its fresh, housemade pasta and a large selection of pizzas, this restaurant is a great spot to host a birthday dinner or any other special occasion. Their famous chili oil-streaked Inferno pizza is a highlight[2][5].
Emilio’s Ballato
Tucked away in the northernmost area of Little Italy, Emilio’s Ballato at 55 E Houston St has been a favorite among celebrities and locals alike since 1956. This cozy restaurant offers a warm atmosphere and a menu filled with Italian classics such as ravioli con ricotta and tagliatelle alla bolognese[2].
Lombardi’s
Often referred to as NYC’s first pizzeria, Lombardi’s at 32 Spring St is a historical gem. Established in 1905, it serves coal oven pizzas that are a must-try for any pizza enthusiast[5].
Grotta Azzurra
For a more upscale and historic experience, Grotta Azzurra at 177 Mulberry St is a standout. Founded in 1908, this restaurant was a favorite of Frank Sinatra and Enrico Caruso. After a stunning renovation, it now offers versatile event spaces and a wide selection of Italian cuisine, making it perfect for special occasions and corporate events[1].
Additional Highlights
Ferrara Bakery & Cafe: Known for its traditional Italian pastries and desserts, this bakery is a great place to grab a sweet treat or coffee[5].
Di Palo’s Fine Foods: This grocery store doubles as a sandwich shop, offering hearty Italian sandwiches and other delicacies[5].
La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels: For wine enthusiasts, this wine bar offers over 1,000 different bottles of imported wines along with small plates like beef tartare and confit rabbit[5].
Practical Information
Operating Hours: Most restaurants in Little Italy are open during lunch hours from 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. and dinner hours from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m., though specific times can vary[2].
Prices: Prices range from $10 to $20 for appetizers, $15 to $25 for pizzas, and $18 to $28 for pasta dishes. Many restaurants also offer takeout and home delivery options[2].
Event Spaces: Restaurants like Il Cortile and Grotta Azzurra offer versatile event spaces suitable for various gatherings, from intimate meals to large celebrations[1][2].
Most Important Facts
Il Cortile and Da Nico are highly recommended for their authentic Italian cuisine and family-friendly atmospheres.
Gelso & Grand and Grotta Azzurra are ideal for larger groups and special occasions.
Lombardi’s is a historical must-visit for its coal oven pizzas.
Emilio’s Ballato offers a cozy atmosphere and Italian classics, having hosted numerous celebrities.
Ferrara Bakery & Cafe and Di Palo’s Fine Foods are great for traditional Italian pastries and sandwiches.
La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels is a top choice for wine enthusiasts.
Restaurants in Little Italy generally operate from 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. for lunch and 5 p.m. to 10 p.m. for dinner, with prices ranging from $10 to $28 for various dishes.
Many restaurants offer takeout, home delivery, and versatile event spaces.
