St. Augustine, with its rich history, charming cobblestone streets, and vibrant culinary scene, offers a diverse array of dining experiences that cater to every palate. Here’s a guide to some of the best restaurants in this historic city.
Catch 27
Located in the heart of downtown St. Augustine, Catch 27 is a standout for its coastal flavors and commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The menu, which changes seasonally, features a wide range of seafood dishes, including fish, shrimp, and clams caught in Florida waters. Highlights include the Deviled Eggs with Fried Oysters, Minorcan Seafood Chowder, and the Rustic Fish. The elegant dining rooms and stylish outdoor patio make it a perfect spot for both casual and special occasions[1][5].
Columbia Restaurant
For a taste of history and tradition, Columbia Restaurant is a must-visit. Established in 1905 in Ybor City and now with a location in St. Augustine, this restaurant offers authentic Spanish and Cuban cuisine in an elegant historic setting. It is renowned for its classic dishes such as the 1905 Salad, Paella, and Empanadas. The restaurant’s ambiance and service make it an ideal spot for special occasions and fine dining[1][5].
Harry’s Seafood, Bar and Grille
Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille brings the flavors of New Orleans to St. Augustine. Located in the historic district, this restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere with a lovely outdoor seating area overlooking the oceanfront. Specialties include Voodoo Shrimp, Blackened Redfish, Gumbo, and Jambalaya. The restaurant also features a great selection of wine, beer, and cocktails, along with live music[2][5].
Prohibition Kitchen
For a unique dining experience, Prohibition Kitchen is a 1920s-themed gastropub that offers elevated pub food and craft cocktails. With the longest bar in St. Augustine, this restaurant provides a lively atmosphere complete with daily live music and intimate booths for a speakeasy vibe. Menu highlights include gourmet burgers, sandwiches, and indulgent milkshakes[2][5].
Collage
Collage Restaurant is an award-winning dining establishment in the Historic District of St. Augustine. Known for its eclectic menu that reflects international flavor profiles, Collage offers fresh local seafood, steaks, lamb, and veal. The restaurant has received multiple recognitions, including “Top 100 Best Restaurants in America” by OpenTable and “The Best Restaurants in the U.S.” by Trip Advisor. The warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with excellent service and a varied wine list, makes Collage a memorable dining experience[2][4].
The Floridian
The Floridian is a great spot for those looking for Southern classics with a modern twist. This restaurant supports local suppliers and highlights the flavors of the region with its farm-to-table menus. The menu features contemporary takes on Southern comfort foods like brisket, cornbread, and grits, along with creative salads and small plates. The lively atmosphere and friendly service make it an excellent choice for lunch or dinner[5].
Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House
Meehan’s offers a multi-faceted dining experience with three distinct areas under one roof. The traditional Irish Pub area is perfect for enjoying a pint of Guinness and swapping stories. For seafood lovers, Johnny’s Oyster Bar upstairs provides fresh seafood and stunning waterfront views of the Matanzas River. Don’t miss the Rueben Egg Rolls and the extensive selection of baked oysters[1].
The Drunken Horse
For a taste of French culinary excellence, The Drunken Horse is a hidden gem in the historic district. This intimate restaurant offers a decadent dining experience with classic French dishes reimagined with a modern twist. From escargot and pan-seared foie gras to coq au vin and mushroom risotto, each dish is crafted with meticulous attention to detail[1].
Forgotten Tonic
Forgotten Tonic is known for its stylish small plates and creative cocktails made using quality spirits. This restaurant is a great spot for evening dining, offering a unique pairing of desserts with craft cocktails. Its inclusion in various food tours highlights its popularity among both locals and tourists[1][5].
Most Important Facts About the Best Restaurants in St. Augustine
Catch 27: Known for its fresh, locally sourced seafood and seasonal menu changes, offering a vibrant dining experience in the heart of downtown St. Augustine[1][5].
Columbia Restaurant: Offers authentic Spanish and Cuban cuisine in a historic setting, making it a culinary icon and a great choice for special occasions[1][5].
Harry’s Seafood, Bar and Grille: Provides New Orleans-style cuisine with a relaxed atmosphere and oceanfront views, specializing in dishes like Voodoo Shrimp and Gumbo[2][5].
Prohibition Kitchen: A 1920s-themed gastropub with elevated pub food, craft cocktails, and a lively atmosphere, ideal for a unique dining experience[2][5].
Collage: An award-winning restaurant with an eclectic menu featuring fresh local ingredients, known for its excellent service and varied wine list[2][4].
The Floridian: Offers Southern classics with a modern twist, supporting local suppliers and featuring a lively atmosphere and friendly service[5].
Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House: Provides multiple dining areas, including a traditional Irish Pub and an oyster bar with waterfront views[1].
The Drunken Horse: A French restaurant with a romantic ambiance, offering classic dishes with a modern twist in an intimate setting[1].
Forgotten Tonic: Known for its creative cocktails and stylish small plates, making it a great spot for evening dining[1][5].
Each of these restaurants offers a unique dining experience that reflects the diverse culinary landscape of St. Augustine, ensuring there is something for every taste and preference.
