True crime podcasts have captivated audiences worldwide with their gripping narratives, meticulous research, and engaging storytelling. Here’s a guide to some of the most popular and highly-recommended true crime podcasts, along with what makes them stand out.
1. Serial
Hosted by Sarah Koenig, Serial is often credited with igniting the true crime podcast craze. The first season, which investigates the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee, set a new standard for narrative podcasting. Each season delves into a different true crime case, offering a deeply researched and empathetic exploration[2][3][5].
2. My Favorite Murder
Hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, My Favorite Murder combines true crime stories with comedy. The hosts share their favorite murder stories, injecting humor and personal anecdotes, making the podcast both entertaining and respectful to the victims. Their unique approach has turned the podcast into a sensation[3][5].
3. Crime Junkie
Produced by audiochuck, Crime Junkie is hosted by Ashley Flowers and Britt Pennella. This podcast covers a wide range of true crime cases, often focusing on lesser-known stories. The hosts’ enthusiasm and thorough research make it a favorite among true crime enthusiasts[1][4][5].
4. In the Dark
Hosted by Madeleine Baran and her team, In the Dark examines the justice system and its failures. The podcast investigates high-profile cases, such as the kidnapping and murder of Jacob Wetterling, and the malicious prosecution of Curtis Flowers. It offers a critical look at how investigations are conducted and the impact on the victims’ families[2][5].
5. Morbid
Hosted by autopsy technician Alaina Urquhart and hairstylist Ashleigh Kelley (also known as Ash), Morbid blends true crime with spooky history and humor. The podcast covers a variety of topics, from serial killers to haunted houses, making it a hit with fans due to its well-researched episodes and charming banter[3][4][5].
6. Criminal
Hosted by Phoebe Judge, Criminal takes a broad approach to true crime, exploring a wide range of criminal behaviors. It delves into the psychology and sociology behind various crimes, making it a departure from the typical true crime podcast format[3][5].
7. Bear Brook
Produced by New Hampshire Public Radio, Bear Brook is a true crime story that involves a serial killer cold case, intrepid reporters, and new DNA genealogy technology. The podcast follows the investigation into bodies found in barrels at Bear Brook State Park, which led to solving murders that went back almost 40 years[2][4][5].
8. RedHanded
Hosted by Suruthi Bala and Hannah Maguire, RedHanded is known for its detailed research and the hosts’ engaging personalities. The podcast covers a variety of true crime cases, often focusing on the more gruesome and lesser-known stories[2][4].
9. Dateline NBC
Based on the popular TV series, Dateline NBC brings true crime stories to the podcast format. Hosted by the Dateline NBC team, it covers a range of cases, providing in-depth investigations and interviews[1][4].
10. Up and Vanished
Hosted by Payne Lindsey, Up and Vanished focuses on missing person cases. Each season investigates a different woman who has gone missing, using non-fiction storytelling skills to delve deep into the cases[2][4].
Key Facts About the Best True Crime Podcasts
Serial is often credited with starting the true crime podcast trend and is known for its in-depth investigations into high-profile cases[2][3][5].
My Favorite Murder stands out for its unique blend of true crime and comedy, making it both entertaining and respectful to the victims[3][5].
Crime Junkie and Dateline NBC are popular for their thorough research and coverage of a wide range of true crime cases[1][4][5].
In the Dark and Criminal offer critical examinations of the justice system and the psychology behind criminal behaviors[2][3][5].
Morbid and RedHanded are known for their engaging hosts and well-researched episodes that often include lesser-known cases[3][4][5].
Bear Brook and Up and Vanished are notable for their detailed investigations into specific cases, often using new technologies and storytelling techniques[2][4][5].
The best true crime podcasts commit to thorough research, factual accuracy, and compelling storytelling, which are key to their success and appeal[3].
The genre has become popular due to its ability to engage audiences through a blend of factual reporting and narrative storytelling, making true crime accessible and engaging for a wide audience[3].
