Key West, known for its vibrant atmosphere, stunning waterfront views, and rich culinary scene, offers a diverse array of dining experiences that cater to all tastes and preferences. Here’s a guide to some of the top restaurants in Key West, highlighting their unique features, menus, and what makes them stand out.
Fine Dining Experiences
Café Marquesa
Located in the Marquesa Hotel on 600 Fleming Street, Café Marquesa is a fine dining gem that has garnered high praise from both locals and visitors. This restaurant is renowned for its impeccable service, seasonal menu changes, and exquisite dishes such as the crispy pork Osso-Bucco and grilled Scottish salmon. The attentive staff and exceptional cocktails, like the pomegranate gin martini, make for an unforgettable dining experience[4].
Four Flamingos – A Richard Blais Key West Kitchen
Four Flamingos, led by celebrated chef Richard Blais, offers a creative culinary journey with a focus on modern techniques and fresh, local ingredients. Situated with stunning waterfront views, this restaurant provides a relaxed yet elegant atmosphere and innovative dishes that integrate Caribbean flavors. It is highly praised for its unique and high-quality fine dining experience[1].
Louie’s Backyard
For a luxurious dining experience with breathtaking sunset views, Louie’s Backyard is a must-visit. Located at 700 Waddell Avenue, this fine dining restaurant boasts indoor and outdoor seating across multiple levels, offering a perfect spot to watch the sunset while enjoying locally sourced cuisine[4].
Cozy and Sophisticated Options
Antonia’s
On Duval Street, Antonia’s has been a staple in Key West’s dining scene for years. Following a recent renovation, this Italian restaurant has elevated its charm, offering a cozy yet sophisticated dining experience. Known for its daily pasta creations and consistent quality, Antonia’s is a favorite among both locals and tourists[1].
Bob’s on Margaret
Nestled in the heart of Old Town, Bob’s on Margaret is a new but already highly acclaimed restaurant. It features a high-end wine selection and a menu crafted by Chef Rodrigo Alvarez, with standout dishes like Sesame Salmon Quinoa and Duck Breast Confit. The atmosphere blends a fun Key West vibe with modern Art Deco decor, making it a lively yet sophisticated dining spot[1].
Casual and Local Favorites
Blue Heaven
For a unique dining experience, Blue Heaven on 729 Thomas Street is a must-visit. This al fresco dining spot is known for its brunch, with a setting that includes palm trees, tropical plants, chickens, and cats roaming the property, and live music. While it’s famous for brunch, Blue Heaven also serves food throughout the day, though brunch is on a first-come, first-served basis[4].
El Siboney
For authentic Cuban cuisine, El Siboney on 900 Caroline Street is a hidden gem. Though it may look unassuming from the outside, the restaurant serves delicious dishes like roast pork, garlic shrimp, and the Cuban Mix sandwich. It’s a bit of a walk from the bustling Duval Street, but the food and portions make it well worth the trip[4].
Amigos Tortilla Bar
Located on 425 Greene Street, Amigos Tortilla Bar is one of Key West’s best cheap eats. This small restaurant specializes in square tacos, burritos, burrito bowls, quesadillas, and nachos. It’s a great spot for casual dining, especially if you’re looking for something close to Sloppy Joe’s and the bars on Duval Street[4].
Other Notable Mentions
Banana Cafe
This little French cafe on Duval Street is a favorite for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. It offers a variety of dishes and is known for its people-watching opportunities[5].
DJ’s Clam Shack
This seafood shack on Duval Street is famous for its clams, shrimp, and conch fritters, making it a great spot for seafood lovers[5].
Origami
For sushi enthusiasts, Origami in Duval Square is a top choice. It offers indoor and outdoor seating and a menu that includes sushi, tempura, and salads[5].
Key Facts About the Best Restaurants in Key West
Café Marquesa: Known for fine dining, seasonal menu changes, and exceptional service. Located at 600 Fleming Street[4].
Four Flamingos: Offers innovative, chef-driven cuisine with waterfront views. Led by chef Richard Blais[1].
Louie’s Backyard: Provides luxurious dining with sunset views, located at 700 Waddell Avenue[4].
Antonia’s: An Italian restaurant on Duval Street, famous for daily pasta creations and a sophisticated dining experience[1].
Bob’s on Margaret: Features high-end wine and modern Art Deco decor, with standout dishes like Sesame Salmon Quinoa. Located at 532 Margaret Street[1].
Blue Heaven: Unique al fresco dining spot known for brunch and a lively atmosphere. Located at 729 Thomas Street[4].
El Siboney: Authentic Cuban cuisine, located at 900 Caroline Street[4].
Amigos Tortilla Bar: Specializes in square tacos and other Mexican dishes, located at 425 Greene Street[4].
Banana Cafe: A French cafe on Duval Street, great for people-watching and various meals[5].
DJ’s Clam Shack: A seafood shack on Duval Street, famous for clams, shrimp, and conch fritters[5].
Origami: Top choice for sushi and Japanese cuisine, located in Duval Square[5].
These restaurants offer a mix of fine dining, casual eats, and unique culinary experiences that make Key West a culinary paradise. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner, a casual meal with friends, or a taste of local flavors, Key West has something for everyone.
