Stonington, Connecticut, a charming coastal town known for its rich maritime history, scenic harbor, and quaint downtown, is also a haven for food enthusiasts. Here’s a guide to some of the top restaurants in Stonington, each offering a unique dining experience that showcases the best of local cuisine.
Breakwater Restaurant
Located directly behind the Inn at Stonington, Breakwater Restaurant is a standout for its waterfront dining. This restaurant boasts stunning views of Stonington Harbor and Fishers Island Sound, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a sunset meal. The menu is filled with seafood favorites, and you can dine inside, outside, or at the bar. A staff favorite is the fish tacos, and the restaurant is known for its welcoming atmosphere under the care of Mari Kodama and her team[1][2][3].
Dog Watch Café
For a casual and fun dining experience, head to Dog Watch Café, situated in Dodson’s Boatyard. This café is beloved by locals and visitors alike for its relaxed vibe and hearty portions of seafood and American fare. While waiting for your table, you can enjoy a beer and a game of cornhole in the ‘Dog Pound’ area. Live music and entertainment are also regular features here. Staff favorites include the lobster BLT and fish tacos[1][2][3].
Noah’s Restaurant
Noah’s Restaurant is a Stonington staple, offering fine dining with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. This family-run restaurant has been serving homemade breakfast, lunch, and dinner for 36 years. The cozy atmosphere, complete with a beautiful mahogany bar and quirky artifacts, makes it a must-visit. Be sure to try their famous seafood chowder and blueberry pancakes, and save room for the decadent desserts like the flourless chocolate cake[1][2][3].
Water Street Café
Water Street Café is another gem in the heart of Stonington Borough, offering a casual yet eclectic atmosphere. The menu features a wide range of dishes, including fresh seafood, meat, and produce from local fishermen and farmers. Owners Stephanie and Walter Houlihan ensure a warm welcome and hands-on approach in the kitchen. Staff favorites include the duck and scallops, and the house-made pasta[1][2][3].
Milagro
For a taste of authentic Mexican cuisine, Milagro is the place to go. Located in the heart of the borough, this quaint restaurant is run by Martin Zavala, a native of Mexico City. The menu features generations-old recipes with a modern flair, including favorites like ceviche de atun and the cinnamon & honey margarita[1].
Indulge Coffee and Sandwich, Co
If you’re looking for a more laid-back setting, Indulge Coffee and Sandwich, Co is a great option. Located across from the Stonington Library, this small café offers a calming atmosphere where you can enjoy sandwiches, breakfast foods, and pastries. It’s the perfect spot to grab a cup of coffee and relax on a lovely day in the borough. The navigator sandwich is a staff favorite[1].
Other Notable Mentions
Stonington Pizza Palace: While not in the immediate borough, this pizza joint in Stonington is known for its specialty pizzas, Greek dishes, and other delicious foods, making it a great option for a casual meal[2].
Buon Appetito Ristorante & Pizzeria: Located in nearby North Stonington, this family-owned Italian restaurant offers a variety of northern Italian dishes in a warm and relaxed environment. It’s a great choice for those looking for Italian cuisine with a Tuscan flare[4].
Most Important Facts About Restaurants in Stonington, CT
Breakwater Restaurant: Known for waterfront dining, seafood, and stunning sunsets.
Dog Watch Café: Offers a casual, fun atmosphere with live music and entertainment, specializing in seafood and American fare.
Noah’s Restaurant: A long-standing family-run restaurant serving fresh, locally sourced ingredients in a cozy atmosphere.
Water Street Café: Provides a casual, eclectic dining experience with a focus on fresh seafood and local produce.
Milagro: Serves authentic Mexican cuisine with modern flair.
Indulge Coffee and Sandwich, Co: A laid-back café ideal for coffee, sandwiches, and pastries.
Local Ingredients: Many restaurants emphasize the use of fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Waterfront Dining: Several restaurants, such as Breakwater and Dog Watch Café, offer waterfront dining with scenic views.
Variety of Cuisine: From seafood to Mexican, Italian, and American fare, Stonington offers a diverse culinary scene.
Whether you’re looking for a fine dining experience, a casual meal, or a relaxing coffee break, Stonington, CT, has a restaurant to suit every taste and preference.
